
SOOOOOO..... I was not a fan of this quote on quote textbook. I was really just confused the whole time by a lot of his wording and lengthy explanations. A comic is a comic not a juxtaposition definition. I feel like he was kind of mocking me the whole time, telling me that he knew more about comics then I did and not to mention he kind of made me feel dumb. I think he may have written the book soul to listen to himself talk.... in well book form. He also was in cartoon form which made me not want to take him seriously. It would have been better if he were somewhat real looking, HE DIDNT HAVE A NECK or EYES.... kinda creepy. The whole pyramid thing really just made me want to reach through the book and punch him, I don't believe that the whole visual arts can be placed inside that pyramid. I also didn't like how he wanted the artists and the writers to be separate to master their skills, I would think that they should be together and master their skills as a whole so that they can work of each other.
Now that I have just bashed McCloud here are some of the things I did like about him and his book:
I loved his semi interesting humor
I loved his definition of art (the whole strip about cavemen, survival and reproduction)
I loved the fact that it was a comic book itself; it kept my attention a lot more then if it was just writing
Finally I liked his drawings they were pretty nice
I feel like I will get a lot more out of this book as the semester goes on and we read more and discuss the graphic novels, but as of right now I'm just not a fan of this book. So if I later make a post about how I connected this book with another graphic novel that we read later then you can disregard this random rant.